The Family Pizzeria You Love is Now Under New Family Ownership!

The Family Pizzeria You Love is Now Under New Family Ownership!

Chances are, you may know the new owner – he was born and raised in your community. He started as a pizza maker at the original Formaggio’s in 2011 while still attending Newsome High School. Pizza and Italian food are his passion, and he’s looking forward to serving you! Give Formaggio’s a try today – and say hello to the new owner, Jordan Moses.

Contact Form

Formaggio's Pizza
Welcome to Formaggio's. Our menu features Fresh Hand Crafted Pizza, Calzones, Strombolis, Subs, Sandwiches, Salads, and more! Try our delicious Margherita, Meat Lovers, or BBQ Chicken Pizza! Find us at Lithia Pinecrest Rd. Order online for carryout or delivery!
Italian Pizza
Casual Dining
Food Types
Vegetarian Options Comfort Food
Service Options
Free Parking
Business Hours
Mon - Wed: Noon - 8:00 PM
Thu - Sat: Noon - 9:00 PM
Sun: Noon - 8:00 PM
Carryout Hours
Mon: Noon - 7:00 PM
Tue & Wed: Noon - 7:15 PM
Thu - Sat: Noon - 8:15 PM
Sun: Noon - 7:15 PM
Delivery Hours
Mon: Closed
Tue & Wed: 4:00 PM - 7:00 PM
Thu - Sat: 4:00 PM - 8:00 PM
Sun: 4:00 PM - 7:00 PM

See what our customers think!

See what our customers think!

"This pizza was so delicious. I am so glad we gave it a try. By far the best on this side of town♡♡"

Stacey R.


"We just ate here for the first time tonight. It was SO GOOD! Really. We finally found our pizza spot! Not only was the food on point, the service was exceptional! We will definitely be back and also order delivery in the near future. And I'm so glad we have leftovers!!! Their portions are fantastic. We had a large pizza with pepperoni and fresh mushrooms, a greek salad and garlic knots with homemade sauce. Do yourself a favor: Go to this little place and order food asap! You won't be disappointed."

Anna C.


"I've ordered quite a few pizzas over the past year since I moved here. Today I got a Philly cheese and wings. OMG so delicious. Love the baked wings and the philly was toasty but not crunchy...meat was tender and cheesy. So great!"

Joe W.


"Confirmed. Best Pizza in Fishhawk. I have tried them all and my only regret is not trying Formaggio's sooner. You live and you learn."

J. Shields


"Amazing pizza! My boyfriend just took me there for the first time this weekend, and the pizza was phenomenal. I am a pizza connoisseur, so I was excited to try it. The pizza slices are huge! They had a deal going on for 2 slices of pizza and a drink for $5 and it was more than enough. They were very accommodating and super nice. I would definitely recommend them to anyone who likes pizza!"

Emilie W.


"Best pizza in town! And for those that have had NY pizza, I will promise u it’s the closest in comparison to NY pizza! Give it a try and u will NOT b disappointed! I promise!❤️🍕"

Annelise R.